On October 19, 2026, the Defense Pricing, Contracting, and Acquisition Policy (DPCAP) issued a memorandum introducing the Guidebook for Acquiring Commercial-First, Version 1.0 issued by Office of the Under Secretary of War for Acquisition and Sustainment to promote the acquisition of commercial solutions. You may wonder, does the new Guidebook reference or supersede the Department of Defense Guidebooks for Acquiring Commercial Items Part A: Commercial Item Determinations or Part B: Pricing Commercial Items? It does not. The new Commercial-First Guidebook neither states that it supersedes those guidebooks nor does it specifically reference them.
What is the Purpose of the Guidebook
The Guidebook was issued to assist the Department of War (DoW) acquisition professionals on identifying, evaluating, and acquiring commercial products and services. For contractors, it provides useful insight into the types of information and support the DoW Contracting Officer will expect when evaluating commercial assertions/determination.
We did not identify any significant changes to the types of supporting data the DoW may request to substantiate commercial determinations. The Guidebook does address the addition of “construction” to the updated FAR 2.101 commercial services of a type definition and also introduces the term “military unique product” to describe a product that is not sold to commercial end-users.
Contractors Should Also be Aware of Several Other Key Considerations
15-day Timeframe to Make a Commercial Determination
The Guidebook incorporates the Deputy Secretary of Defense’s September 14, 2026, memorandum, “Fostering One Strong Industrial Base,” which requires commercial determinations be completed within 15-days of a receiving a complete request from a contractor. Unfortunately, the Guidebook does not define what constitutes a “complete request.” We did note the 15-day requirement was added to DFARS 212.001-70(d)(1) as part of the Defense Federal Acquisition Regulations (DFARS) Revolutionary FAR Overhaul (RFO) Class Deviations and is clearer and stricter. It requires the contracting officer to provide either a commercial determination or a decision that the product or service doesn’t meet the FAR 2.101 commercial definition within 15 days of receiving the contractor’s response to a solicitation. Given this uncertainty, you need to ensure that commercial assertions and supporting documentation are as comprehensive as possible when initially submitted in response to a solicitation.
Although the Guidebook identifies the DCMA CIG as a great resource for supporting market research, determinations, and price reasonableness analyses, it also emphasizes that Contracting Officers must abide by the DCMA CIG’s determination, unless the request is withdrawn before the determination is issued. While we support the effort to accelerate commercial determinations, the success of this initiative will depend in part on the DCMA CIG’s ability to meet the compressed review timelines. We are hopeful that schedule pressures do not inadvertently lead to non-commercial determinations based on timing constraints.
Written Commercial/Noncommercial Determinations Required for Acquisitions
The Guidebook makes a point that for every acquisition exceeding the Simplified Acquisition Threshold (SAT), the DoW contracting officer must prepare a commercial determination and if commercial products or services cannot be acquired, or do not meet the FAR 2.101 commercial product or service definitions, the contracting officer must document the basis for a noncommercial determination in writing. The requirement to prepare written determinations of noncommercial was added to DFARS 212.001-70(c) as part of the Defense Federal Acquisition Regulations (DFARS) Revolutionary FAR Overhaul (RFO) Class Deviations.
Contracting officers must upload both commercial and non-commercial determinations into the DoW CID Database found in the Electronic Data Access (EDA) Module in the Procurement Integrated Enterprise Environment (PIEE) within 30 days of contract award. While the requirement to upload commercial determinations has been in place for some time, the requirement to upload noncommercial determination is a significant new process.
Contractors Can Request Commercial or Non-Commercial Determinations
Although contractors do not have access to PIEE, 10 U.S.C. §3456 requires Contracting Officers to provide a copy of a commercial or non-commercial determinations upon request from the contractor or subcontractor offering the product or service (10 U.S.C. §3456). Contractors and subcontractors should routinely request copies of all Contracting Officer commercial and non-commercial determinations relating to their products and services including determinations issued by the Defense Contract Management Agency (DCMA) Commercial Item Group (CIG). Commercial determinations made by DoW can be used as a basis for submitting proposals with commercial products or services. Obtaining the noncommercial determination will be beneficial to understanding the basis leading to the decision of noncommercial.
Artificial Intelligence
The Guidebook discusses the use of Artificial Intelligence (AI) tools to assist contracting officers in preparing well-structured, legally defensible determinations. It clearly emphasizes that AI cannot make a commercial determination or replace a contracting officer’s judgment, rather it is intended to streamline market research, analysis, and the documentation process.
While I didn’t think AI would be effective, AI can be useful in conducting market research and identifying products or services with comparable functionality. As a result, AI has the potential to enhance market research and support commerciality analyses, provided it is used as a tool to support rather than replace judgment.
Focus on Performance-Based Acquisitions
The guidebook is looking to increase the use of performance-based acquisitions which may create market research opportunities for both the department and contractors. A performance-based acquisition focuses on the requirement, in other words the functions to be performed, the performance outcomes required, or the essential physical characteristics of a product or service. Those are the key factors to consider when comparing proposed products to similar or of a type products in the marketplace.
Takeaways
If you anticipate submitting a commercial assertion in response to an upcoming solicitation, begin your market research and prepare your comprehensive data package as early as possible. The 15-day timeframe for Contracting Officers to issue a commercial determination is very tight and leaves little room for delays or supplemental information requests. Although the Guidebook indicates the clock begins when a contractor submits a “complete request” the Guidebook doesn’t define it and DFARS specifically states the 15 days is upon contractor’s response to the solicitation. Contractors should make every effort to ensure their initial submission is thorough, well documented, and supported with sufficient evidence to substantiate the commercial assertion.
The Guidebook can be a valuable resource to contractors to help ensure that submitted documentation meets the Government’s expectation. It outlines the types of supporting information that should accompany a commercial assertion. The Government expects a side-by-side table that clearly identifies similarities and differences between the proposed and similar commercial products, not a narrative.
Additionally, construction is now clearly a commercial service.
If the DoW Contracting Officer has previously issued a commercial determination for your product/service, we recommend obtaining a copy for your records. Maintaining a copy can support future proposals. Non-commercial determinations can also provide valuable insight into the Government’s commerciality analysis and help support future commercial assertions.
Introduce your buyers and subcontract administrators to the guidebook as a resource.
Preparing Commercial Assertions for DoW Acquisitions
Preparing a commercial assertion early gives government contractors time to identify gaps in supporting information before responding to a solicitation. Redstone GCI assists with developing commercial product and service descriptions, documenting market research, and preparing comparisons that explain how proposed products or services relate to commercial offerings. Our team also assists with reviewing supplier documentation, organizing determination files, and updating purchasing procedures and training so buyers and subcontract administrators understand the documentation needed to support commercial assertions.


Lynne is a Director with Redstone Government Consulting, Inc. providing government contract consulting services to our clients primarily related to Commercial Item Determinations and support, Cost Accounting Standards, DFARS Business System Audits, Proposals, and Incurred Cost. Prior to joining Redstone Government Consulting, Lynne served in several capacities with DCAA and DCMA for over 35 years. Professional Experience Lynne began her career working with DCAA in the Honeywell Resident Office, Clearwater, FL in 1984. Lynne’s experience included various positions which involved conducting or reviewing forward proposals or rate audits, financial capability audits, progress payments, accounting and estimating systems, cost accounting standards, claims and disclosure statement reviews. She is an expert in FAR, DFARS, CAS and testified as an expert witness. Lynne assisted in drafting the commercial item guidance for DCAA Headquarters. Lynne was assigned as a Regional Technical Specialist where she provided guidance to 20 field offices on highly complex or technical issues relative to forward pricing, financial capability or progress payment issues. As an Assistant for Quality, she was involved in reviewing and ensuring audit reports were in compliance with policy and GAGAS as well as made NASBA certified presentations to the staff including but not limited to billing reviews, CAS, unallowable cost and progress payments. To enhance her experience in government contracting, Lynne accepted a position with DCMA in 2015 as part of the newly organized DCMA Cadre of Experts in the Commercial Item Group. This included performing reviews of prime contractor’s assertions and/or commercial item determinations as well as performing price analyses. Lynne was a project lead and later became a lead analyst where she engaged with the buying commands on requests and reviewed price analysis reviews performed by a team of 5 analysts. She also assisted the DCMA CPSR team relative to commercial items and co-instructed the Commercial Item Training presented to DCMA. Education Lynne earned a Bachelor of Science Degree in Accounting from the University of Central Florida. Certifications State of Florida Certified Public Accountant State of Alabama Certified Public Accountant Defense Acquisition Workforce Improvement Act (DAWIA) Level III- Auditing DAWIA Level III – Contracting