--- title: Do Federal Employee Labor Unions Believe Contractor Employees are Paid Too Much? description: Contractor employee compensation spurs a heated debate and leads to several reform measures. image: https://info.redstonegci.com/hs-fs/file-236562161-jpg/images/redstone-government-consulting.jpg --- [ PAY INVOICE](https://redstonegci.com/invoice-payment/) [Call Us Today 256-704-9800](tel:2567049800) [info@redstonegci.com](Mailto:info@redstonegci.com) [![Redstone_Logo](https://info.redstonegci.com/hubfs/redstone%20logo%20version%201%20-%20rgb-1.png)](https://www.redstonegci.com/) # Do Federal Employee Labor Unions Believe Contractor Employees are Paid Too Much? [Posted by Darryl Walker on Fri, Jul 26, 2013 @ 08:07 AM](https://info.redstonegci.com/blog/author/darryl-walker) - [Tweet](https://twitter.com/share) ![redstone government consulting, cost and pricing and budgeting](https://info.redstonegci.com/hs-fs/file-236562161-jpg/images/redstone-government-consulting.jpg?width=1000&name=redstone-government-consulting.jpg) All one has to do is read a recent article written by David Cox, President of the American Federation of Government Employees (AFGE), to derive the answer to this question, and the answer is that contractor employee compensation should be brought in line with the salaries that public sector employees (e.g., federal civilian personnel) are paid. The lengthy July 15 2013 article written by Mr. Cox, and published within the Bloomberg BNA on-line Federal Contracts Report, does correctly acknowledge that the OMB is revisiting its benchmark data to determine if the underlying compensation wage survey information, as well as the approach used to project reasonable future year contractor executive employee ceilings, are accurate. And the article narrative also walks the reader through four contactor compensation reform measures “pending before Congress” which offer remedies to the “outrageous and unnecessary premiums” paid for contractor services. The impact of the four proposals on reductions to allowable contractor compensation ceilings range from modest adjustments in calculation strategy, which would result in a small deduction to existing compensation caps, to more draconian measures, the most dire of which would dispense with using commercial market-place wage surveys in gaging reasonable compensation ceilings and thus relegate ceiling benchmarks to public servant compensation levels (e.g., annual base salaries paid to heads of Executive Department Agencies, the President, or Vice-President). This latter bi-partisan proposal, according the Mr. Cox, “rejects the proposition that private sector executive compensation should determine how much taxpayers must contribute to the yearly compensation of the federal government’s richest contractors”. In case you have not figured out which of the four proposals Mr. Cox believes is best for our country, it is the latter—measurement of annual compensation to our senior government leaders and ostensibly to that leadership’s effectiveness in running our country. The article is anything but objective and is obviously crafted in a manner to draw empathy for the plight of federal workers and their dilemmas with frozen pay levels and furloughs due to huge budget deficits. Were it not, however, for the continuous and redundant interjection of clichés intended to seek pity for the working person (this includes everyone but contractor personnel) who have made sacrifices during periods of budget reductions, a reader could, in a very few instances, take the article’s discussion more seriously. The article overpowers logic with hyperbole, one example of which is a badly worded metaphor suggesting that routing Forest Service aircraft to release “lovely fragrances” over Washington (in lieu of fire retardants) would not be enough to “conceal such an appalling stink (e.g. trends in excessive compensation for contractors) especially when working and middle-class Americans are making significant sacrifices in order to reduce the federal government’s deficit.” The AFGE’s attempt to connect legitimate wage dilemmas facing federal employees to selecting a reasonable method for measuring contractor executive commercial-based salary ceilings, in this writer’s opinion, fell short of that objective, and such a connection is obviously irrelevant to the necessity of ensuring FAR Part 31 Cost Principles ensure reasonable benchmarks for allowable contractor employee compensation in a commercial market environment. [![Learn More About Our Human Resources Consulting Services](https://no-cache.hubspot.com/cta/default/203971/interactive-169319629357.png) ](https://info.redstonegci.com/hs/cta/wi/redirect?encryptedPayload=AVxigLKJ%2Bo9ZXK6Q6q71ECjsmZUvh3%2Fh0zWziI3bLFwn9F1OUSz69iZww2NqyI4pIyejvpPMDbDmunxcGjdXq1r6vYlBsl9o40UIcdAjaX7rxd9moXxnD5cfJpRC%2FQ47GGc6Nc%2BnATzjkl3519%2F1GABb3HEVGEU0tUOWmQznhYnIjBJBHEjWM37KUY8HzwX3ucnFtQ1s89005UKPpXzesur0dQ%3D%3D&webInteractiveContentId=169319629357&portalId=203971) ### Written by [Darryl Walker](https://info.redstonegci.com/blog/author/darryl-walker) ![Darryl Walker](https://info.redstonegci.com/hubfs/images/Staff_/Darryl-Walker.png) Darryl Walker is a Emeritus Advisor for Government Compliance with Redstone Government Consulting, Inc., and formerly served as an Owner and Technical Director for the Beason & Nalley Government contract consulting group for over ten years. He provides content for our Government Insights Newsletter, provides training courses to government contractor and business community leaders, and consults with government contractors regarding a vast range of issues including cost proposals and presentations, internal controls, proposal preparation, compliance with the FAR and Cost Accounting Standards, litigation support, specialized claims, defective pricing issues, liaison with procurement and DCAA audit officials, and accounting and management systems compliance. Prior to joining Redstone Government Consulting, Darryl worked with the Defense Contract Audit Agency (DCAA) for almost 34 years in a variety of technical and management capacities. During his tenure with DCAA, Darryl provided audit services to a wide range of government agencies, including the Department of Defense, NASA, Department of Energy, Department of Interior, General Services Administration, and Department of Justice. During his experience with DCAA, Darryl audited over 3,000 government contractors throughout the Southeastern United States, Europe, and the Middle East. Education Darryl is a graduate of Texas Wesleyan College with a major in accounting and minor in economics. ## About Redstone GCI Redstone GCI is a consulting firm focused on fulfilling the needs of government contractors in all areas of compliance. With a singular mission to help contractors through the multiple layers of “red tape,” we allow contractors to focus on what they do best – support their mission with the U.S. Government. We are home to a group of consultants made up of GovCon industry professionals, CPAs, attorneys, and retired government audit and acquisition professionals. Our focus and knowledge of audit and compliance functions administered by DCAA and DCMA will always be at the heart of what we do. However, for the past decade, we’ve strategically grown to support other areas of the government contractor back-office with that same level of focus and expertise. We’ve added expertise in contracts management, subcontract administration, proposal pricing, various software systems, HR and employment law, property administration, manufacturing, data analytics/reporting, Grant specialists, M&A, and many other areas. When we see a trend in the needs of contractors, we act to ensure we can provide the best expertise in the market to fulfill those needs. One thing our clients can be certain of is that with the Redstone GCI Team in your corner, there is no problem too big and no issue too technical for our team to tackle. Topics: [Proposal Cost Volume Development & Pricing](https://info.redstonegci.com/blog/topic/proposal-cost-volume-development-pricing), [Employee & Contractor Compensation](https://info.redstonegci.com/blog/topic/employee-contractor-compensation) ### Search Posts This is a search field with an auto-suggest feature attached. - There are no suggestions because the search field is empty. ### Subscribe via E-mail ### Latest Posts ### Posts by category - [Accounting System Compliance (282)](https://info.redstonegci.com/blog/topic/accounting-system-compliance) - [Commercial Determination (34)](https://info.redstonegci.com/blog/topic/commercial-determination) - [Contractor Purchasing System Review (CPSR) (85)](https://info.redstonegci.com/blog/topic/contractor-purchasing-system-review-cpsr) - [Contracts & Subcontracts Administration (300)](https://info.redstonegci.com/blog/topic/contracts-subcontracts-administration) - [Cost Accounting Standards (CAS) (60)](https://info.redstonegci.com/blog/topic/cost-accounting-standards-cas) - [COVID-19 (23)](https://info.redstonegci.com/blog/topic/covid-19) - [Customer Success Story (2)](https://info.redstonegci.com/blog/topic/customer-success-story) - [Cybersecurity (28)](https://info.redstonegci.com/blog/topic/cybersecurity) - [DCAA Audit Support (249)](https://info.redstonegci.com/blog/topic/dcaa-audit-support) - [Defense Procurement & Acquisition Policy (DPAP) (7)](https://info.redstonegci.com/blog/topic/defense-procurement-acquisition-policy-dpap) - [Deltek Costpoint (54)](https://info.redstonegci.com/blog/topic/deltek-costpoint) - [DFARS Business Systems (179)](https://info.redstonegci.com/blog/topic/dfars-business-systems) - [DOD IG (10)](https://info.redstonegci.com/blog/topic/dod-ig) - [Employee & Contractor Compensation (22)](https://info.redstonegci.com/blog/topic/employee-contractor-compensation) - [Employers & Unions (8)](https://info.redstonegci.com/blog/topic/employers-unions) - [Estimating System Compliance (18)](https://info.redstonegci.com/blog/topic/estimating-system-compliance) - [Export & Import (19)](https://info.redstonegci.com/blog/topic/export-import) - [Federal Acquisition Regulation (FAR) (187)](https://info.redstonegci.com/blog/topic/federal-acquisition-regulation-far) - [Federal Construction Contracting (4)](https://info.redstonegci.com/blog/topic/federal-construction-contracting) - [Government Compliance Training (59)](https://info.redstonegci.com/blog/topic/government-compliance-training) - [Government Property Management (18)](https://info.redstonegci.com/blog/topic/government-property-management) - [Government Regulations (265)](https://info.redstonegci.com/blog/topic/government-regulations) - [Government Shutdown (9)](https://info.redstonegci.com/blog/topic/government-shutdown) - [Grants & Cooperative Agreements (2 CFR 200) (32)](https://info.redstonegci.com/blog/topic/grants-cooperative-agreements-2-cfr-200) - [Human Resources (118)](https://info.redstonegci.com/blog/topic/human-resources) - [Incurred Cost Proposal Submission (ICP/ICE) (83)](https://info.redstonegci.com/blog/topic/incurred-cost-proposal-submission-icp-ice) - [Litigation Consulting Support (17)](https://info.redstonegci.com/blog/topic/litigation-consulting-support) - [Manufacturing Operations Consulting (26)](https://info.redstonegci.com/blog/topic/manufacturing-operations-consulting) - [Material Management & Accounting System (MMAS) (23)](https://info.redstonegci.com/blog/topic/material-management-accounting-system-mmas) - [Non-US Government Contractor (3)](https://info.redstonegci.com/blog/topic/non-us-government-contractor) - [Office of Federal Contract Compliance Programs (31)](https://info.redstonegci.com/blog/topic/office-of-federal-contract-compliance-programs) - [Organizational Change Management Consulting (17)](https://info.redstonegci.com/blog/topic/organizational-change-management-consulting) - [Paycheck Protection Program (PPP) Loans (8)](https://info.redstonegci.com/blog/topic/paycheck-protection-program-ppp-loans) - [Program Management & Project Cost Control (2)](https://info.redstonegci.com/blog/topic/program-management-project-cost-control) - [Proposal Cost Volume Development & Pricing (79)](https://info.redstonegci.com/blog/topic/proposal-cost-volume-development-pricing) - [Quickbooks (21)](https://info.redstonegci.com/blog/topic/quickbooks) - [REAs, Claims & Terminations (10)](https://info.redstonegci.com/blog/topic/reas-claims-terminations) - [Redstone GCI (50)](https://info.redstonegci.com/blog/topic/redstone-gci) - [Sequestration (4)](https://info.redstonegci.com/blog/topic/sequestration) - [Service Contract Act (14)](https://info.redstonegci.com/blog/topic/service-contract-act) - [Small Business Compliance (121)](https://info.redstonegci.com/blog/topic/small-business-compliance) - [System Award Management (SAM) (9)](https://info.redstonegci.com/blog/topic/system-award-management-sam) - [UKG Ready HR Software Consulting (7)](https://info.redstonegci.com/blog/topic/ukg-ready-hr-software-consulting) - [Unanet (35)](https://info.redstonegci.com/blog/topic/unanet) - [Vlog (41)](https://info.redstonegci.com/blog/topic/vlog) ### Disclaimer *Data published on our website, such as our white papers, blogs and other government contracting commentary reflect our interpretations and opinions of current events and regulations, at the time such data is published, and the perspectives/opinions of other professionals in our industry may vary from our own.  Further, our commentary and perspectives do not reflect legal analyses, since we are not attorneys, but rather government contracts and accounting advisors.  We therefore make no representation that the use of our published information will insulate a company from government challenges, nor otherwise ensure a successful defense on any government procurement adverse action.  Readers agree that articles or blog commentary presented within our website shall not be replicated or re-published without requesting before publication in another medium, and our expressed written consent to do so.* **Redstone Government Consulting** 501 Madison Street SE, Suite 100 Huntsville, AL 35801 **Phone: ** [256.704.9800](tel:2567049800) **Email Us**[ info@redstonegci.com](mailto:info@redstonegci.com) **[PAY INVOICE](https://redstonegci.com/invoice-payment/)** [PCI DSS compliance documentation](https://redstonegci.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/10/pci_dss_self_assessment_certificate.pdf) © 2026 Redstone Government Consulting | All Rights Reserved | [Privacy Policy](https://redstonegci.com/privacy-policy/) | [Event Refund / Cancellation Policy](https://redstonegci.com/event-refund-cancellation-policy/)